Ask a Pro

Welding basics: Deciding on a type of welder

Welding

No comments

What's the difference between a simple, wire-feed electric welder and a more expensive model that allows shielding gas to be used? I'm tempted by the lower price of the basic welder, but I wonder what I'd be losing. –Myles Catherwood, Thornhill, Ont.

A wire-feed welder is very easy to use because it automatically advances a thin wire into the weld area. As with all electric welders, it works by creating an arc that generates enough heat to melt the metal being joined; however, this process also leads to an undesirable side effect. The culprit is oxygen. Heat causes oxygen to react chemically with molten metal unless steps are taken to protect the weld zone while it’s hot.

Self-shielding welding wire and shielding with an inert gas that flows out of the tip of the welder during use are two ways to manage the oxygen reaction. The least expensive wire-feed welders are typically designed to use self-shielding wire only. They don’t have the features necessary to connect to a tank of inert gas and direct that gas down to the tip of the welding gun. More expensive welders, on the other hand, can use both self-shielding wire or bare wire, plus a separate shielding gas–whichever you like. Self-shielding wire is much more expensive than ordinary welding wire, but you don’t need to rent a tank and buy gas.

Self-shielding wire is made for general-purpose welding involving steel. A coating on the outside of the wire vaporizes during use, creating the chemical protection necessary for a good weld. Self-shielding wire creates strong welds, but the results don’t look as smooth as what you’d get from more expensive, gas-shielded, wire-feed welders. (You can see the difference in the above illustration). That’s one main difference between the two machines. Gas-shielded welders (also called MIG welders, which is short for metal inert gas) are also capable of welding aluminum with the appropriate welding wire.

Illustration by Paul Perreault

Steve Maxwell

Steve Maxwell lives on Manitoulin Island, Ontario and has worked remotely as technical editor of Canadian Home Workshop since 1990. He uses his experience as a cabinetmaker, carpenter and stonemason to prepare projects for the magazine, to write stories of his own, and to test and review products and tools in his workshop. Steve has a readership of about 2 million people across Canada and the US, and takes photos and creates videos to accompany his work.

When Steve’s not working with words, wood and stone, he likes to spend time gardening, cutting firewood, and showing his five kids how to make things.


No comments

To leave a comment, please log in

Don't have an user account? Register for free

Poll

How do you heat your home?

Loading ... Loading ...

Recommendations